Friday, January 10, 2014

The Magic Diversity Challenge - A New Year's Resolution

My regular readers know me as a father who is raising two young men and that Magic the Gathering has provided me with a meaningful way to connect with my younger son. I can't help but look at the Magic Community from the perspective of a parent and how it will impact on his development. Most of the time, I see what every gamer sees - a wonderfully supportive environment full of learning and social interaction. Other times, I see or hear about a behavior that isn't as supportive. This article isn't about pointing a finger at behavior that we find unacceptable. Rather, it is about two wonderful groups that have taken it upon themselves to help combat unacceptable behavior, spread the good word about the benefits of diversity in gaming, and ultimately, a challenge to every person in our community who has a chance to influence it for the better.

Traditionalists believe that you should start every New Year with a resolution to improve yourself or some aspect of the world you inhabit. Many people with special interests tend to make resolutions that focuses on their area of interest. Today, I'm going to share with you my resolution for 2014 in the area of Magic the Gathering. I'm doing so in the hopes that after you read this, you'll adopt it for yourself. I doubt everyone will who reads this article will do so - but I'm sure many of you will.

If you have the fortitude to step over the line in the sand with me, you'll make a difference to the way we all interact with our community for the better. If think you have what it takes, then read on as I introduce two wonderful people to you: Tifa Robles (@tifarobles) of the Lady Planeswalker Society and Trevor Murdock of Planeswalkers for Diversity.




::::Q&A::::
Question: Would you both take a moment to introduce yourselves and explain how you became involved in Magic?

Tifa: I’ve been playing video games and family board games my entire life. Games have always been a passion and inspiration of mine. In college, I started playing strategy games, starting my addiction with Settlers of Catan and learning games of all types. Eventually, I started working at a board game store where not only did my collection and knowledge grow rapidly, but I was introduced to Magic tournaments. I fell in love with the atmosphere and the excitement of the new release of M11 before I even learned the game itself. It wasn't long before my boss sat me down and taught me the basics in a Winston draft (not my recommended learning tool). My spark was instantly ignited. I started competing heavily within my first month, and it wasn't until then that I realized the sexism integrated in the Magic community. I had loved the friendly people in my shop, but once I was sitting across the table from them as opposed to selling them cards behind the counter, their attitudes took a turn for misogyny. Suddenly, it was considered silly for me to think I could be good at Magic and conversations about my breasts were completely acceptable to have right in front of me. I competed in a GP, and not much later a few PTQs. I never did very well, but I worked hard. I wanted to prove to all those critics and judgmental bigots that women could be competitive and could succeed in the Magic scene. I was also judged by my looks and the clothes I wore A LOT! It was disgusting. After nine months, I was near the end of my college career and needed to find a real job. I was very interested in work at Wizards of the Coast and had a friend recommend me for Customer Service/Game Support. I worked there during my last three months of college and six months later was hired onto the Magic Brand Team. It was a great opportunity that taught me a lot about Magic, the community, and myself. But recently, after two years on the team, I left to help grow LPS more than I could with the constraints of being a Wizards employee. LPS is now a global organization with nearly twenty chapters that have started nationwide, constantly gaining national attention from many media outlets, that only now I can be involved with. [Ed. note: Tifa also blogs regularly, you can find her here].

Trevor: I actually started playing Magic in the ‘90s, the way it was intended: while friends were creating role-playing game characters. After my playgroup went separate for various reasons, I was left with a single deck (featuring pestilence rats and pestilence) and no one to play with. Several years later, when my oldest daughter started being interested in card and board games, I nabbed a Guildpact Izzet Gizmometry theme deck so we could play. Eventually my daughter lost interest but I found a casual playgroup. One of the members suggested I check out the competitive scene to help the group deal with M10 rules changes. After FNMs, drafts, and one pre-release later, I was  hooked. After becoming an FNM regular and then interested in PTQs and GPs, I started Booster Victim as a way to poke fun at the steep learning curve in Magic. What started out as humour led to a serious interest in making Magic more accessible to everyone.

Q: What event made you realize that you needed to create your group and how old is your group now?

Tifa: It wasn't until female friends of mine showed an interest in learning and playing at my house, away from the men who knew how to play in our lives, that I realized the desire and need for a female-friendly group. The group started in April 2011 and moved into an official capacity in stores in July 2011.

Trevor: I had just started following some Magic folks on Twitter in late 2012 because of Booster Victim, when a trans player, Feline Longmore, won the SCG Seattle Legacy Open, and it was the online onslaught of disgusting (and irrelevant) comments about her gender and her being trans that led me to search for some kind of LGBT support group for Magic players. I just assumed such a thing would exist given how large the Magic community is. When I couldn't find one, I started a Facebook group. I didn't know about LPS at that time and when someone pointed out that it already existed I asked Tifa if I should shut down the group and invite people over to LPS. Instead she actually encouraged us to maintain a separate presence and grow it into more than just a Facebook group; she understood that we would have a wider reach by operating both groups and collaborating.

Q: What about your personal background made you feel you were the right person to start your respective organizations?

Tifa: I have always been deeply passionate and caring about equality - especially when relating to gender issues. Not that I feel it is required, but my background in feminism helps my personal determination push LPS forward. I feel like I understand the deep undertones of sexism and the importance of awareness. Awareness is the first step to progress. Plus, my experience with Magic is varied in a wide range. I was a store employee at tournaments; a participant in tournaments in many levels; an employee at Wizards in two different, very important roles; and I was friends with people in all levels of play from beginner through Pro. I've also always enjoyed event organizing and feel I’m a natural leader. Plus, the sexism and mockery of my group has only pushed me harder because of how relevant and necessary my group is, instead of discouraging me to slow down.

Trevor: Honestly, I don't think I'm the right person to be leading Planeswalkers for Diversity. I think I was one of the right people to co-found it but I hope that in 2014, we garner enough attention to attract new leadership. I do have a lot of experience running (and forming) other non-profit groups though, and I knew I could draw on that and be persistent enough to put in place the building blocks of an organization that will have a big and lasting impact on environments in which Magic is played. For LGBT issues in particular, I am a resource person with the Positive Space Network at the University of Victoria. I co-lead workshops to train other resource persons, so I also have some experience specifically in creating safe spaces to draw from. I think that helped give me a good grounding to express what I am passionate about, which is all about places where Magic is played being inclusive to everyone, not just people of a particular gender, age, race, ability, sexuality, or anything else that has nothing to do with playing a competitive trading card game!

Q: How would a Magic player become involved with supporting your group?

Tifa: It’s as simple at spreading the word in a positive light, joining our group, liking our page, following my Twitter, etc. If you want to make a bigger impact, there is always the option of starting a local chapter, but this takes a huge time commitment that not everyone can commit to. More than anything, we just want to be acknowledged and accepted as a serious group and part of the community.

Trevor: Ditto, though I would also add that we are open to writers at website and to people joining our stream team.

Q: What do you see as the biggest challenge facing our Community?

Tifa: Being comfortable with what has been acceptable for years and not wanting to change. Everyone has to change. Even people who are not acting or speaking offensively need to call others out on their behavior. This can be scary and seem hopeless, but it really is the only way. Just think, in 5, 10, 20, 100 years, we will all look back at this and know which side was in the right. I don’t think anyone looks back at the 1800s and says, “We never should have given women the right to vote. What a mistake.” At least those that do aren't taken seriously.

Trevor: There is an insidious and deeply ingrained attitude that goes like this: "I'm not actually a woman hating homophobe myself so I can say rape jokes or 'that's so gay' and it's fine because I don't mean ill will towards anyone by it." And as Tifa says, even those who aren't comfortable with this attitude because they know it makes the environment too intimidating or uncomfortable for some people are often afraid to speak up because they don't want to be seen as a party pooper. The analogy I like to make though is with that of judges. Often judges tell us things we don't want to hear, and rulings that favor your opponent can suck. But, the presence of judges is vital to maintaining the overall fun level of the game vs. Magic event devolving into a gnarled mass of heated rules arguments. In my book, failing to speak up about non-inclusive language is just like spectating a game and failing to speak up about an illegal play.

Q: What is the biggest challenge facing your respective organization's growth?

Tifa: Being understood and accepted. We are often considered “sexist” ourselves before people even know
what we are. We are not an exclusive club for women only. In fact 60-70% of our player-base is male - mostly husbands, boyfriends, fathers, and brothers, but also friends. In addition, we need to be taken seriously. For example, some competitive players refuse to play at LPS because we are welcoming to “beginners” but we really want all skill groups playing together. We have a member who placed second at a PTQ and many others who are very competitive and really good at the game, and we also have women who are just learning almost every week. We don’t want any woman to say, “That group is not for me,” before they try it out at least twice (since attendance can vary drastically).

Trevor: Our biggest challenge is the same in terms of being understood and accepted, but it looks a little different for us. Although our mandate is broad and about inclusiveness in Magic for everyone, we tend to have an LGBT focus because after women this is the biggest target group for discrimination in the Magic community, and LPS already exists with a spotlight on women. Sometimes this comes across as if we think racism and other forms of discrimination are less important than homophobia, bi-phobia, and trans-phobia (not to mention the fact that LGBT itself is shorthand). Many of our volunteers are not members of the LGBT community themselves and sometimes get accused of being politically correct or "white knighting" which is a pretty ridiculous and off base insult to lob at people who just want to make Magic more enjoyable for more people.

Q: How has the Magic community responded to your groups? Has the response surprised you in any way?

Tifa: It has surprised me on both ends of the spectrum. There has been A LOT of positive response, including articles and interest from well-known writers and commentators in the community, a chapter started and supported by members of LoadingReadyRun, and many Magic-celebs that have even attended LPS when they are in Seattle. I’m constantly grateful for this loving support and hope it continues to grow.
Unfortunately, the reverse side has been just as strong. There are a lot of people who consider us sexist (as mentioned before), stupid, ridiculous, and even the most annoying and demeaning of descriptions: adorable. The forum pages I have found have sickened me with anger, but that means we just need to work harder to crush their opinions and prove them wrong.

Trevor: Similarly, I've been surprised at how readily several pros have been willing to donate their time and energy to joining us on stream, giving us short interviews for our “Peek” series, and spreading information about us. On the reverse side, the fact that so many people think it's more important to use language they consider funny than be sure they are not contributing to a toxic playing environment can be discouraging. I'm also disappointed that we only have a handful of local playgroups so far, though I'd rather have a few very successful and impactful groups than a pile of floundering ones. At least we span multiple continents with our small number of groups: currently the biggest local P4D chapter is actually in Australia. Someone needs to dethrone them!

Q: Since starting your groups, who has been your biggest supporter?

Tifa: As silly as it is to say, my husband. He has not only supported all of my desires for the organization, but challenged and motivated me to go further. It was his idea to start a second chapter in the Seattle area (on the Eastside). In addition, he attends every event with me and makes sure I stay fed and hydrated as I host the tournament. He also helps teach at conventions and constantly gains members and support from big names on Twitter. Without him, LPS wouldn’t be what it is today.

Trevor: Aside from co-founder Nelson Salahub, I would have to say Tifa, actually. Without her I think P4D would have just been a Facebook group that I started hoping someone would take over. I probably would have given up on it without her encouragement and her setting an example with LPS of how much can be accomplished with some persistence to providing some leadership.

Q: Diversity is a watchword that appears to be gaining popularity in recent years. Why do you think it has become such an important topic?

Tifa: It’s part of our cultural evolution to critique our society and make it better. As equality becomes more normal and expected in places like the working world, this will spread into other spaces as well, like hobbies and lifestyles.

Trevor: Specific to the gaming community in particular, we tend to be people who were outcast in some way growing up ourselves and we tend to be people who understand the value of constructive criticism. So it's just bound to happen that someone is going to point out the severe ironic hypocrisy of being hateful towards others because of some external thing about them that has nothing to do with gaming.

Q: If you could fix one problem, address one shortfall, or focus on one aspect of our Community - and do so through the actions of your group - what would it be? Is there something that is a close second?

Tifa: I just don’t want my Magic skills, or anyone else’s for that matter, judged based on my genitals, face, or any other unrelated feature. I want my Magic skills to speak for themselves.

Trevor: Ditto! We just focus more on the "unrelated" part, especially LGBT-ness.

Q: Have either of you run into any unexpected opposition to your group?

Tifa: I expected opposition, but some of the extreme opposition has been shocking. Mostly the crazy far-fetched conclusions about my intentions or my group’s views.

Trevor: Honestly, I'm less surprised by opposition than underwhelmed by support. I don't want to diminish all of the support we have gotten, and we have a handful of incredible volunteers who have made massive contributions to the organization so far. But from the broader Magic community, putting myself in the position of being a Tournament Organizer, or running a Magic-related website, etc. and coming across this group, I sort of think we should be overwhelmed by folks asking to help us out. Obviously I'm biased in being passionate about this an important cause or I wouldn't have started it, but I'm hoping people just didn't know about us and will start coming out of the woodwork to support our mission in 2014.

Q: What do you have planned for 2014?

Tifa: Bigger, better exposure.

Trevor: Actual real life presence in events, more diversity-and-Magic themed content on our website, and regular streaming. Tangible goal for 2014 is by the end of the year, I'd like it to be commonplace to see Planeswalkers for Diversity (and Lady Planeswalkers Society) t-shirts at Grand Prix and on Pro Tour coverage, and for major events to have members of their welcoming booths trained in creating safe spaces for women, people of color, LGBT-folk, and people with disabilities.

We are off to a good start with an invitation from the organizers of GP Sacramento coming up shortly. Now we just need some volunteers!

Q: Every leader has a vision. Where do you see your group in 5 years?

Tifa: I hope my group is known to every engaged Magic player.

Trevor: Well the ultimate goal is to fold because there is no longer any need to point out the benefits of being kind to strangers that you play a competitive game with, but realistically 5 years is too soon for that so I'll stick with expansion of the goals for 2014 but with global coverage not just Australia and North America.

Throwing Down the Gauntlet
Tifa and Trevor, in addition to offering a great interview about diversity, are asking for everyone's help. Everyone who reads this article can contribute - at the end of it I'll even show how players can get in on the action. The main challenge is being made to all Professional Players, writers and bloggers, content managers, website owners, Tournament Organizers, store owners, Judges, and Podcasts. If you provide content or support the community in any way, we're throwing the gauntlet down at your feet. This challenge is also being directed to Wizards of the Coast, to recognize 2014 as the year they make a difference in diversity through their worldwide influence. It doesn't matter if you reach one person or ten thousand through your actions, the idea is simple.

Make a pledge to make supporting diversity in gaming this year through your words and deeds.

The Pledge
As a supporter of Magic the Gathering, you recognize the impact of your contributions. Every day, you see the effect you have on the greater Magic Community. Now it's time for you to take the pledge:

I promise that in 2014, I will make every effort to support diversity. Through my actions, I will effect change and work to end bigotry so that all players will feel welcome. To that end, I will do the following-
  • As a writer or blogger, I will dedicate at least one article to promoting diversity.
  • As a Professional Player, I will seek a way to promote diversity at events I attend.
  • As a content manager, I will work with my writers and media specialists to make certain they promote diversity. I will also take up the pledge personally through my own blog or Twitter feed.
  • As a website owner, I will promote diversity through the content I provide. I will take care to highlight articles that promote Diversity and make those items easy to locate on my site.
  • As a Tournament Organizer, I will offer a free table to any group promoting diversity in gaming and/or I will sponsor at least one side-event to help promote Magic as a safe and interactive game anyone can enjoy. If I offer gaming coverage, I will do a PSA to run at each event promoting diversity.
  • As a Store Owner, I will establish and post a policy that all gamers may feel welcome and that bigotry and hate speech will not be tolerated. I will also investigate becoming a Safe Place.
  • As a Judge, I will be an ambassador for diversity, helping everyone to see the advantage of an open and friendly gaming environment.
  • As a Podcasterer, I will dedicate one episode this year to taking on the diversity challenge and I will promote diversity through my podcasts as the opportunity presents itself.
  • As WotC, we will pledge to promote diversity through our articles, website, and event coverage.
  • As a player, I will take the Gamers Against Bigotry pledge. I won't let my fellow players get away with hate speech and I will notify a Judge when necessary at sanctioned events - even if I am not the person receiving the insult.
Seems easy, right? Here is the best part. There are already two groups that support diversity in the Magic Community. You can contact either of them directly to get their perspective on any number of issues affecting the gaming community. Doing your own interview with Tifa or Trevor will fulfill your pledge. Spend an article talking about their respective groups will do the same. I'm not suggesting that everyone who takes the pledge should limit themselves to these suggestions. I'm only offering them as one way to fulfill your obligation to promote diversity. Be creative!

When you write your article, promote your podcast, or find another way to fulfill your pledge this year, then let Tifa and Trevor know about it. Both Planeswalkers for Diversity (@MTGDiversity) and the Lady Planewalker Society (@MTGLadySociety) have Twitter feeds, and they will be happy to retweet your success to their followers. In this, everyone wins.

Don't Forget Those Judges
We would be remiss if we did not mention an important part of the Magic Infraction Procedure Guide as a part of this article. While we hope and work towards changing the mindset of players, the IPG provides for a method of handling situations that do occur. Unsporting Conduct - Minor or Unsporting Conduct - Major are penalties that can be issued to players that engage in vulgar or hate speech. The IPG is a very well defined document and we all encourage players to be familiar with it and the possible ramifications of violating it. When in doubt - call a Judge.

2014 - The Year We Make a Difference
At the start of every New Year, it is customary to take make a resolution for some type of self-improvement or to perform an act of goodwill. Here is mine:

I promise to give this article to every content site for Magic the Gathering to be used to help promote diversity. I further promise as a blogger, to write at least one additional article promoting diversity and to continue to assist Planewalkers for Diversity and the Lady Planeswalker Society in their mission.

You see that first sentence? If you are responsible for managing a site, you have my permission (as well as Trevor's and Tifa's) to take this article right now and post it in its entirety, so long as you credit the source and keep it intact. If there is a need to edit it, please contact me first via email. You also may take the article to simply distribute it to your own writers to get them to write about diversity this year. This article, interview, and pledge are all one big challenge to the Community.

Are you willing to take the challenge?

Monday, December 23, 2013

2013 Wrap Up, Predictions, and Wishlist

For my last post of the year, I think it important to revisit a few stories that still have some relevance to me, as well spend some time looking forward to next year.  Before we get started though, I have to offer a big thank you to my son Jacob, for dragging me into the world that is Magic the Gathering.  Without him I would have never met some wonderful people, learned about the most amazing game in the known universe, or found a real opportunity to express myself in print.  This has been a great year for me and I have my son to thank for that.  I can only wish that my readers have a chance to develop the same type of relationship with a child, parent, cousin or other family member.  Magic has become our common language.  Mr. Garfield, wherever you are - you are a mage of the first order for having created this wonderful experience that we can share.

For me, 2013 was about two different worlds of Magic.  The first world was about my personal experiences.  Everything from the most trivial - learning about a card interaction - to the most difficult - deciding to work towards becoming a Judge.  My first world was filled with wonder, sometimes daily as I learned one of the most complex yet accessible games I've ever been exposed to.  Kids play it, but true mastery only comes with years of experience.  I yearned regularly not just for new cards but also to understand Magic at a level that many people seem to take for granted.

I started the year privately thinking being a Judge would be a wonderful way for me to become more deeply engaged with the game and community.  As I spent time playing, the thought grew until it wouldn't go away.  Since about halfway through this past year, I've been on a personal quest to become a Judge.  I know others have done it faster, but that doesn't bother me in the slightest.  I'll get there, and when I do I'll do my best to represent the community in a manner that promotes the game, Wizards, and my local stores.

On the other side, I became involved in the larger 'Community'.  I use the capital 'C' here only to emphasize the difference between my local opportunities to play Magic and the national and international Magic communities.  By writing about Magic, even independently, I quickly gained the attention of a broad audience.  With a little help from Twitter and a lot of help from well timed articles supported by some caring Magic community members, I received enough attention and positive reinforcement to keep writing.  If this is the first time you're reading me, I encourage you to go back and take a look at some of my other articles - particularly those that I'll highlight here.

If Wishes Were Horses, Beggars Would Ride
My best writing this year is hard for me to pin down.  Personally what I think of my best achievement had to do with overcrowding at GPs and what I thought could be done to improve them.  Since then, I've learned how far in advance WotC tackles issues.  It wouldn't surprise me in the least to find out that they were already considering how preregistration could be improved to prevent surprises the morning an event started.  I still feel a small sense of pride though thinking back to the events that transpired this year, and what effect I may have had on them as a single gamer - especially given how happy most players seem to be with this change.

Looking forward, there are some things I'm hoping for in 2014.  Here are just a few of them:


A Revision to the HoF Voting System
I still think this needs to happen.  Fan involvement is what makes the Community tick.  The selection process and final voting for the Pro Tour Hall of Fame leaves a bitter taste in every fan's mouth for two weeks every year.  Yes, I understand that Pro's put in a tremendous amount of time and energy to get to the point where they are worthy of consideration.  I don't want to devalue that.  But to sit on the sidelines while every relevant conversation about Magic for two weeks straight is about something that has nothing to do with any of us is tough to swallow.  Fans should have a way to contribute meaningfully - even if our total vote value only contributes to a weighted 20% of the final evaluation.  I stand by this position, and I wish other fans of Magic would take up this cry to review and revise the existing system to make it more inclusive.

Develop Community Recognition or...
I'm deeply torn about this next issue.  Part of me very much wants to see several of the changes I wrote about here happen in the next year.  If nothing else, a broader system for recognizing those that make important contributions should be put into place.  But then we read an article like this one - The Day Kibler Shut Down the World by MTG Color Pie - and I know I have to reevaluate my priorities.  What is more important?  After reading Robby's article, if I had to choose between the two changes I'd want his idea to happen.  Even though his article is incomplete, it is easy to gather his intent.  While I don't play on MODO myself, I can see how important a concept like this is to the long term health of Magic as an online commodity.  I think Robby has identified the crux of the problem facing WotC.  His solution, while more complicated than maintaining the status quo is certainly worth consideration.  I hope for the MODO players the world over that his concept or one of a similar ability to improve MODO is considered by WotC.

The Next Un-Set
If 2013 was the year of Modern Masters, Gods, and the revitalization of WotC's support of EDH, then what could 2014 bring?  Aside from a couple of known quantities (crosses fingers for continued EDH support) I predict the next rabbit that will be brought forth from the WotC hat is the long overdue third Un-set.  Unglued was released in 1998.  Unhinged was released in 2004.  Given just that information alone, I'd say we're overdue for the third Un-set by about 4 years.  Add in 2013 was the year that Magic celebrated it's 20th anniversary, I'd say the best way to start off next year would be to announce by April that the next Un-set is on its way before the end of the year.  Call me a hopeless romantic, but I really love the idea of those silver bordered cards and full art lands.

Supplemental Product(s)
I'd like to see a supplemental product in 2014 along the lines of another Planechase set.  Why?  Judging by the popularity of the Game Day event of facing the Hydra for Theros and word of a similar activity for Born of the Gods, team style gameplay seems to be on WotC's mind lately.  It's not a stretch to think that Planechase will be due for an expansion as a result.  If not Planechase, then Archenemy or Vanguard will be highlighted this year (or a new, undisclosed format such as Hoard).

Growth
This one is so easy to predict that I decided to keep the Amazing Kreskin locked up in his room so I could do it myself.

Magic in 2013 saw unprecedented growth.  And if 2013 was good, 2014 will be even better.  Modern has been given a shot in the arm from Modern Masters (I missed the mark on this when I wrote about the inflated cost of it - but I still hold to the principal).  Legacy is alive thanks to continued efforts by SCG and other local play groups.  Add in the excitement we've seen in the RTR block and the wide acclaim of Theros, and you have a recipe for success.  This growth does have an important consideration though that WotC and TO's will need to keep in mind - Professional Players matter.  You don't have to like them, follow them on Twitter, or give them a second thought.  As a fan of Magic, you're allowed your opinion.   Truth is though, they dedicate an obscene amount of time to trying new decks, playtesting, and traveling.  It's not an easy life, and it's far from lucrative (not counting writing or endorsement deals, your average 5 people working at Wal-Mart likely make more in a year than any 5 Pros).  Pros matter though to the continued visibility of the game.  They matter to new fans, who need someone to look up to.  And they matter to events, where their rumored and/or guaranteed attendance surely draws in some players that may be on the fence about going themselves.  People do jump at the chance to meet LSV or get a playmat signed by Reid.  So while some may make fun of Pros, look to 2014 as a year WotC and TO's will spend more time figuring out how to make Pro Magic players happy.  If you love Magic as much as I do, put on your big boy pants and move away from worrying about what they are complaining about in a given week.  If they have a valid point (and most of the time they do), don't knock them.  I'm not saying don't test them by arguing them.  After all, the best way to find the holes in an argument is to poke at it.  I'm just suggesting that you step back and realize, as a participant in the process, that they often have a point that is worth consideration, even if we don't get it from our perspective.  They do a tremendous amount for the game as ambassadors and deserve if not your respect, then at least your tolerance.

Increased Visibility and Acceptance
There are two organizations in the community which now receive insufficient attention from fans - and I believe that 2014 will be the year that changes for the better.  The Lady Planeswalkers Society (Facebook page) believes in creating, "A welcoming, friendly environment for women to learn & play Magic: the Gathering!" Led by Tifa Robles, the LPS has had some growth during the past year, but I'm sure they'd like more. Tifa recently left her job at WotC with an intent to give greater attention to her love of promoting Magic through her group.  It's my hope that the LPS will aggressively develop new markets - every major metropolitan area should have their own chapter of the Society - as well as promote their message at major GPs.  The other group that is I think is on the cusp of a real watershed moment is Planeswalkers for Diversity.  Created by Trevor Murdock, their mission is as follows, "This group was created to facilitate networking and sharing of ideas between Magic Players who are interested in creating a safe environment for people to play the best game on earth regardless of their gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, race, age, or anything else that has nothing to do with it."  In a nutshell, I think that Trevor's vision is that Judges will never have to be called on to make Unsportsmanlike Conduct calls, but more than that Trevor sees Magic the Gathering as a chance to create a perfect microcosm of society - one where no one ever has to worry about who they are or what other people may think of them when they sit down to their match.

My Personal Magic 2014 Wishlist
  • Develop a winning record at Limited Draft
  • Meet great people - my shortlist includes Erin Campbell, any of the Judgecast Judges, LSV & more
  • Become an L1
  • Find a home as a writer
  • Eternal Weekend comes back to Philadelphia in the fall
  • Both of the LGS's I use have a banner year in Magic
  • Helene Bergeot doesn't ever leave WotC
  • Use more pictures in my articles - everyone likes card art and kids playing Magic
  • Design and complete a special project to help others learn Magic (I have SUCH the idea...)
  • That I get every [REDACTED] to [REDACTED] with me next year (Spoilers!)
  • Increase my reach via Social Media
  • Get to play hundreds of games with my friends and Jacob
  • And that everyone that plays Magic has an even better year than I hope to have.
With that, I leave you until 2014.


Magic Blessing
May you always have mana a plenty,
May all your spells resolve,
May you topdeck every card you want,
May you find a way to win against all odds,
And until we meet again friend,
May you play with intelligence, honesty, and grace.



~And Jim, wherever you are when you read this, thank you.

_______________________

Reblogs, Retweets, & Mentions of all kinds are appreciated - as an independent writer I'm only read when others like what they see and share with their friends.

Monday, December 16, 2013

Getting There

As I watched my beloved Dallas Cowboys make another series of mental mistakes on offense this past Sunday leading to yet another preventable loss, something struck me.

I'm the Tony Romo of my LGS.

I'm not cute.  I'm no good with the ladies.  And I don't have millions in my bank account.  I'm Tony Romo because of my play style in Magic.  This revelation set me back.  It made me realize that something in me needs to change.

Let me take you back to a conversation I had at my LGS just a few nights before...

Another One Bites the Dust
It was getting to be late in the evening.  I'm wasn't tired but I also wasn't feeling great about continuing to play.  The deck I was pretty satisfied with at the start of the night had betrayed me.  My record for the evening was poor and I was questioning myself and my choices.  I sat down across from my opponent.  She looked at me and asked how I was doing.  Instead of responding with a platitude, I told her the truth.

Drafting Theros earlier that night, I felt that I had a pretty solid deck.  B/G, with a fair number of tricks.  I judged it to be solid, albeit with a slightly higher curve than I felt comfortable playing.  After playing a couple of opponents though I realized something was wrong with it.

I shared it with a friend who was pretty much everyone's go to for deck tech questions.  He looked through it, pausing occasionally to point out a good trick or a solid beater.  After he was done he did something he had never done before with one of my decks.  He handed it back to me.  He then looked up and said, "Seems ok, you should win some tonight with that.  Your curve is a little high, but B/G can be like that."  In the past when he had looked at decks for me he always had some advice.  This time though, he seemed to think otherwise.  Instead of laying it all out by color and mana cost to figure out how best to tweak it, he took a pass by handing the deck back to me.  This action alone told me that I had a good deck.  Sure, I probably didn't need one or two cards in there - but most were strong contributors to the strategy that revolved around B/G Theros draft decks.

So when I sat down across from Sarah, I opened up.  I don't think I had won a game at that point - and oddly enough neither had she.  I knew her to be strong player and one who thought more about her plays that most of the people in the room.  When I spoke, it felt like a confessional.  I felt a burden lift off my shoulders as I confided in her.

Heartbreak Hotel
"I'm not doing great tonight, but you knew that [seeing as how we were paired against each other].  I pulled a decent deck, but I just can't seem to 'get there'.  I can't close the deal and win matches with this...this mess.  Actually, I think it's how I play, I think I just don't do well closing out at the end.  I watch others do it all the time - especially to me.  They always seem to have the right combat trick or ability to overwhelm me at the last second.  Situations where I think I'm in control turn into one-sided beatings.  I know I'm close, but I must be playing wrong."

We played our matches then.  The first game was the same old story.  Sarah beat on me, and pretty easily too.  She beat on me so badly that she was actually apologizing.  Second game I won.  But it was the second game that I realized something.  As I was playing against Sarah, I felt like I was always in a better position.  I had a stronger board state at every step of the game.  I was in control.

And yet, I never felt that I was 'there'.  I never thought I was in control enough to put the game away.  Each move I made was calm and calculated to do two things.  Never leave me exposed to a counter-attack and to never overstep myself in my own attacks.  I wasn't playing to win - I was playing to eventually make it across the finish line.  And this isn't the first time.  When situations call for calm and collected, I'm hot and fast.  When I'm supposed to be pressing the advantage I find myself shoring up my defenses.  And when I'm supposed to be patient and hold back a trick, I'm always worrying that if I don't pull the trigger now that I won't get a better chance.  My ying and my yang are diametrically opposed to the point where I'm my own worst enemy.

Game three?  Sarah was apologizing again.  It felt like Foreman/Ali, and I was playing rope-a-dope.  Only thing was, I wasn't Ali.  I had no plan to come back.

Bitter Little Pill
The draft ended following our match.  If it didn't, I probably would have begged, 'No mas' and run home with my tail between my legs.  I was stunned.  How did I go 0-4 with such a solid deck in Theros draft?  I felt the answer was there, just waiting for me to pick it up off the white plastic table.  Instead, I put my coat on, picked up my bag and left the store.

I drove home that night thinking of plays, missed and otherwise.  I tried to recreate some defining moments in my head but was unsuccessful.  I'm just not one much for recall after a round is over and I'm not great on notes.  Perhaps that is something I need to start to do so I can go back and look at how to improve.  In the meantime, I need to get back to the comparison.

We Aren't the Champions
My man, Mr. Tony Romo, threw away another critical game last night.  As I watched him and the Cowboys play in the final 15 minutes, I realized something.  He was a part of a broken system.  The offensive play calling was atrocious.  As quarterback, Tony could have and should have recognized that.  He is the face of the team, the general on the field.  All he had to do was call an audible, switch to a run and move the sticks.  The Cowboys were pushing too hard when they should have been burning clock time, deliberately moving forward.  Even at the very end, when they had sufficient time to not rush and get the job done, they still made bad calls and executed poorly.

Tony was executing a plan, not unlike I was the other night, without thinking about the consequences.  Or he was thinking too much and trying to do more than the hand that he was dealt would let him.  The Cowboys threw the game away - just as I think I've done too many times to count.  In Magic, you have to know when attack and when to sit on your hands.  You have to understand when to slow the game down and when to go no huddle.

Failing to understand these things and you end up like Romo.  Ineffective when it matters the most.  As an outsider, it is easy for me to see why Romo failed on Sunday.

I don't know the reason for each of my game losses on Friday.  But as I was the one holding the cards, I know I bear responsibility.  So to find a way to stop losing, I need to start to take a few moments each game to try to take the long view.  I need to look at how my opponent is playing and what they're playing and it will effect me.  I need to realize that there are times that I need to change my posture from attack to defense - and vice versa.

But most of all, I have to realize one important thing.  It's what Romo has to realize as well.  The cards didn't betray me.  I betrayed them.  I'm done being my store's bad example of a player.  I hope Tony looks back on last night's game and realizes something similar.  Maybe then we can both be Champions.

_______________________

Reblogs, Retweets, & Mentions of all kinds are appreciated - as an independent writer I'm only read when others like what they see and share with their friends.

Friday, December 13, 2013

The Great Twitterment of '13

Both during and after last weekend, Twitter erupted with another round of arguing between MtG professional players and personalities.   This 'Twitterment' developed as a result of an simple question about of all things, deck names.

Twitterment - noun 1. An argument that takes place over Twitter.  Often lasting less than 48 hours due to lack depth or permanence of the discussions being held.  Either that, or the holders of the argument realize the futility of carrying on at a rate of 144 characters a post. 2. A silly website that sends followers to you for a 'low, reasonable fee' - similar to the concept of buying friends.

The Twitterment started innocently enough.  An innocuous comment posted and likely initially forgotten, about the naming conventions used for creating deck names.  That was all it took.  The MtG Twitterverse erupted, picking sides and printing banners.  War paint was issued, battle plans were drawn, and people chose sides.  Was the Pro magic player right?  Maybe.  Did it matter to anyone not in the line of fire?  Probably not.

If I want to call my deck, "Stoke the Fires, Here Comes the Carol Burnett," then that is what I want to name it and YOU can't do anything about it.  There is no requirement that states my deck name must reflect what my deck does or does not do, what my personal values are, or what type of childhood trauma I may suffer from.  Nowhere in the Comprehensive Rules is this issue directly addressed.  People are allowed to name their deck anything they want.  So long as the chosen names are not offensive, they can be anything.  It can be a paragraph long and describe every aspect of the deck, or it can be one four letter word that doesn't relate at all to the contents or purpose.

I always wanted to name a deck, 'Fred'.  "Hey Magic Dad, what is your deck's name?"  "Oh, it's Fred."  "Fred?"  "Yes, Fred."  "What's it do?"  "It's a WU Combo-Control deck."  "I don't get it, why Fred?"  "Why not?  It's my deck.  Somebody decided I needed to name it and I thought 'Fred' was a good, strong name.  You have a problem with that?  Well, do ya?"

But the Pro didn't make a statement about a rule.  The Pro made a general statement about deck names and from that point forward, the Magic sub-community of Twitter had a new topic to beat to death.  It is fun watching the Twitterment evolve.  First there is shock, "What did they say?"  Then there is a bit of denial, "There is no way I agree with your stance...and your hair is stupid."  Eventually, we come around to acceptance, "..."  The Twitterment peters out and a new topic is started.  Unless someone with some juice comes along to restart it, the argument at this point is dead - and in many cases undecided.  Who won?  Who lost?  Why did they say that thing about my hair?

Fallout
Great Twitterments though should not be forgotten but is the nature of the format that they fall to the ravages of time.  Instead of losing them forever, they should be dragged out from whatever hole they crawled into and examined at least once more in the cold, stark world of bloggers.  In this instance, while maybe not a 'great' Twitterment, the MtG Deck Name Controversy of GP Dallas/Fort Worth 2013 should be reviewed once more.  So what can we learn from this Twitterment (and perhaps others like it?).

First, as a consumer and fan of the MtG Community, I need to state that I am becoming less surprised when these Twitterments erupt.  In fact, it happens with such regularity that there are certain evident truths.  Those truths are, in no particular order:
  • You can almost smell the wind change just before a Twitterment starts
  • Pros are reasonably consistent about which side of an argument they will take
  • Unless a Pro weighs in, a Twitterment typically fizzles within 20-30 Tweets
  • Pros and MtG Personalities should have ranks - there are obviously generals and majors and sergeants and privates in these wars
  • Certain people have the power to end Twitterments, depending on the topic
  • The power to end a Twitterment by means other than letting it run its course diminishes exponentially by the number of minutes it's been in force and the number of Pros involved
  • WotC sees everything - just because they haven't commented, doesn't mean they aren't watching
  • Twitterment length is better determined by who is involved than topic
  • Unless the Twitterment is about an event or circumstance that hasn't happened, it will conclude in 48 hours
  • All contributing circumstances must be taken into account when predicting how long and nasty the Twitterment will be
In the case of the most recent Twitterment, what really added fuel to the fire was something no one could have seen coming.  A savage ice storm hit the Dallas/Fort Worth area just before the event.  A number of pros canceled their plans to attend leaving them with free time.  And we all know what happens when guys have too much free time on their hands - they find ways to get into trouble.

Second, a good Twitterment provides an important service.  It gives Twitter users a release valve for the community to express itself.  Many community members dedicate a great deal of time, money, and personality to the pursuit of a perfect deck.  Others feel a connection to some of the popular Professionals and personalities.  A good Twitterment can be cleansing, a chance to blow off some pent up steam.  It also allows for WotC and others to see and weigh in on what is important - at least this week - to the Pros and other players who follow them.  Even better, a good Twitterment can be enjoyed and contributed to by all.  Something as universal as deck names appeals to every Timmy, Johnny and Spike.  Even better, there isn't anyone that can't contribute to the argument.

Perhaps most important of all, a Twitterment provides us with a chance to see which Pro is the whiniest, most self... - err, no, that's not right.  Let's travel back to Brian Kibler's attack of MtGO for just moment.  When he was booted from the MOCS he was participating in and lashed out via Twitter and his blog, he wasn't saying anything particularly unique.  Players have complained about the reliability of MtGO for some time, especially in larger events.  So people who claim, "I had to unfollow [insert name here] because I couldn't take their complaining anymore," should really think for a moment about what happens when Pros do complain.  A strong Twitterment, well thought out and hard fought by one Pro, can do something that takes 50 or more other regular grinders to do.  It can effect change on a large scale.  Will MtGO be fixed as a result?  Probably not fully, but I can guarantee that it will be better.  The net result here is a win for the fans.  It doesn't matter if you play MtGO or not, the MODO item was a victory for us all.  Why?  Because - if Kibler won this time about MtGO and it results in an improvement, perhaps it will embolden LSV to make a point about drafting that has long irked him and would result in an improved experience at sanctioned drafts.  Or another Pro such as Del Tora could take up the banner about a needed website improvement.  Success is its own positive reinforcement.

[Side note: WotC is tremendously responsive to all fans, I've had some wonderful conversations with them and I don't spend thousands of dollars in a month on MtG, nor am I a Pro.  There is no denying though that Pro's voice with their legions of followers carries serious weight].

So how does this most recent debate stack up to something like the MODO EXPLODE-O?  Not very well I'm afraid.  But it did provide some entertainment for a few hours.  I'm sure this past argument had everyone thinking, just a little bit, about how they name their decks.  Even if it doesn't affect you now it will sometime in the next year.  You'll find yourself filling out a decklist at some event and you'll actually ask yourself - does Big Greenie/White Weenie really describe what I'm trying to do?  Or better yet, you'll wonder about whether or not you really want to use the cutesy name you came up with on camera when you pull a dark horse and get to the Top 8.   Anything is possible.

And when I win with my Fred deck at some major event, most of you will understand.  Except for those Pros that think this matters - the ones who do can go pound sand.  It's my deck, and I'll party with it however I want to.

_______________________

The list below is incomplete, but if you feel any difficulty in coming up with a name that is suitable for event coverage you could do worse than start here.  Anyone who is interested in a full sized .pdf or would like to see some terms added, then please email me with "DECK NAMES" in the subject line.



_______________________


Reblogs, Retweets, & Mentions of all kinds are appreciated - as an independent writer I'm only read when others like what they see and share with their friends.  

Saturday, December 7, 2013

Sometimes, you just get lucky...

So a few weeks ago (before he was grounded for reasons), my younger son Jacob and I were at a Friday Night Magic Draft held in our LGS.  I've been helping with the drafts recently in my quest to become an L1, but this story isn't about me.

No, this is about one 12 year, a Theros draft, and his march to have his first 5-0 night.  Sounds promising?  Well read on...

From Humble Beginnings
Jacob rarely turns in better than a 2-3 performance.  He's hit a wall in his drafting.  Improving his skills is something he and I talk about occasionally.  Most often, we spend some time reviewing some of the latest strategies handed down by the great Limited Resources podcast.  For those that don't listen to Marshall and Brian, I'm sorry.  Actually, I'm not.  It's your loss and you can live your life the way you want.  I won't judge you.  I'll just hope that you're in my pod when we get to draft.

This night was no different from any other.  Angels didn't drop out of the sky to ordain him.  A gypsy woman didn't stop and glare meaningfully at us.  Weird, alien looking green men didn't circle our house in a freakish space ship.  Rather, Jacob and I piled into my truck and started our path to the store as we do any other Friday night.  On the way, I was determined to repeat some of the wisdom I had picked up that week listening to Limited Resources.  We talked a bit about what colors are strong and what some key cards are in the format.  I was trying to keep things both simple for Jacob and also educational - pointing him in a direction that I thought played to his strengths.

I know that BREAD was also a topic of conversation that evening (and how do I know? - because almost every conversation about drafting includes it).  BREAD (Bombs, Removal, Evasion, Aggro, Duds) is the lifeblood of picking cards in any draft or designing a sealed pool deck for play.  We haven't gone much deeper than BREAD and color philosophies in a given block.  When talking about BREAD, I try and focus on reminding him that using it correctly gives him a fighting chance.  Even with my pep talk and new wisdom to share about colors in this draft, I was worried about how he'd approach his draft that evening.

The reason is Jacob had reached that point where for him, he felt there was little left to discover in Theros draft.  I could tell by talking with him that he was almost as confident as he becomes when looking at a draft format.  I could also tell that he had reached that dangerous point many of us reach - that he was in danger of becoming bored with it.  When one becomes bored of a thing (a game format, surfing big waves, or whatever your thrill is), it is easy to lose respect of that thing.  And that is when it reaches up and bites you in the backside.

Prepwork Makes it Easy
When we were both first learning to draft, I was watching other people as much as I was trying to figure out what two color combos were most dangerous.  Before you all going off half cocked and screaming at me in the comments section, let me clarify.  I wasn't cheating.  I was most definitely respectful of other players as they made selections.  Rather, I was watching for tricks and steps that would make it easier for Jacob and I to focus more on drafting and less on mana, tokens, and other garbage.

So when Jacob arrived that night, he was as ready as I could make him.  Sure, he has to take care of his stuff, but we both have the following (thanks to Bank of Dad, where all gamers get their start):

  • 1 Fat Pack box
  • 150 sleeves of the same make and color
  • About 100 lands (twenty of each color), sleeved in 2/3rds of the sleeves
  • Tokens (some of mine are sleeved to accommodate my OCD)
  • Dice/Counters
  • A method to count life
He'll also have a few other items as will I.  His bag often includes something to drink, perhaps a snack, some trades and his favorite playmat.  Depending on his mood, he'll either have his EDH deck or his current super-jank standard deck.  This kit hasn't changed since the second or third time we drafted.  Sure, his sleeves have been replaced.  He's even updated the Fat Pack box.  But truth is, this is as near to perfect as I can make it for him.  I still have yet to see a better or easier setup than what we use.

Why is this great?  Our setup allows us the maximum amount of time needed to decide how to build our decks.  Neither of us goes to time.  We always have a nice, comfortable margin left over after we've completed making our picks.  This is most beneficial when our draft goes sideways halfway into our picks.  It gives us the maximum time left on the clock to figure out how to build an optimum deck.

After you here about his draft though...you'll realize that he needed all of five minutes.  And three of those were spent looking at his cool loot.

The Draft to End All Drafts
Let's get it out of the way.  Pack 1, pick 1 was the Foil Anax and Cymede.  Spare the melodrama about him picking a dual color card first in a draft format that isn't based on a two color system.  Anytime you can grab an Anax and Cymede as your first pick, it's rarely the wrong thing to do.

He went red from there, picking up some choice cards.

Pack 2, pick 1 was the Stormbreath Dragon.  At this point, he knew that he was Red and likely white.  But when people are passing you Skullcleavers and Lightening Strikes, you practically can't go any other way.

Pack 3, pick 1 was the Spear.  Pick 2?  The Titan.

You just can't make this stuff up.  And yes, he ended up with a playset of Skullcleavers and Lightning Strikes.  For those interested, his complete draft list will be at the end of the article.  I'm just sorry I couldn't tell you specifically what order he received all of these picks.  To say he was happy following the draft was an understatement.  Was it 'perfect'?  Probably not.  But it was as close as most of us will get.

Integrity
No one needs to know how he beat one opponent after another that night.  No one needs to hear the step-by-step dismantling he handed out to player after player.  And for certain no one needs to hear about how one of his victims played me in a match-up towards the end, destroyed me in two, then looked at me and said, "Consider that payback for Jacob beating me earlier tonight."  (Yes this did happen folks.  Truth is stranger than fiction).

What you need to hear is that Jacob reached the big table.  Game 5, the last one of the night, he and one other player were undefeated.  The other player was twice Jacob's age, weight, and and probably three to four times the experience looked him right in the eye when they first sat down and offered a draw.  He knew that Jacob had a bonkers deck and quite frankly didn't really want to play against it.

At first, Jacob was a little bit confused.  Understandably so, given this was the first time he'd ever been offered a draw.  His opponent explained, fairly, that a draw meant that neither would win, but then neither would lose.  Given the position of the rest of the field, they'd both end up on top for the night.  No mention was made of splitting prizes.  My kid is no dolt though and got it right away - and he also understood that at most he was probably throwing away two packs.

Jacob only thought about it for a moment but said, "No, I want to play."  Running through his mind were two things - his deck was fabulous and he wanted to be 5-0, not 4-0-1.  I could see it.

Game one, his opponent came out of the gates fast running a more white/red deck (Jacob's deck was more red than white).  Jacob had difficulty finding a mountain, and it was all over.  Game 2?  Same story in reverse. Jacob manhandled his opponent.  Before he started game 3, I looked at him and said I was proud of him so far, and no matter what he was coming home with a decent amount of prizes.

Game 3?  It was longer than both of the first games put together.  But in the end, Jacob lost due to an inability to put together the right mana base.  Variance happens.

Truth Is...
I know a truth though about that night.

Jacob didn't lose.  Sure, technically he lost the last match.  But that night he was special.  He was on fire.  He saw that it was possible to do amazingly well, and he handled it in a mature manner.  The best part for him wasn't the draft.  It wasn't finding a way to 2-0 nearly all of his opponents.  It was from where I sat, his standing up and stating, "No, I'm want to play."

That my friends, is a victory.


Jacob's TOTALLY BRUTAL R/W Theros Draft
Creatures
1 Akroan Crusader
1 Akroan Hoplite
1 Anax and Cymede (Foil)
2 Arena Athelete
1 Borderland Minotaur
1 Cavalry Pegasus
1 Favored Hoplite
1 Deathbellow Raider
4 Minotaur Skullcleaver
1 Stormbreath Dragon
1 Titan of Eternal Fire
1 Traveling Philosopher
16 Total

Spells
4 Lightning Strike
1 Rage of Purphoros
1 Spark Jolt
1 Spear of Heliod
7 Total

Lands
9 Mountains
8 Plains

Sideboard
1 Breaching Hippocamp
1 Crackling Triton
1 Decorated Griffin
2 Ephara's Warden
1 Evangel of Heliod
2 Fleshmad Steed
2 Lagonna-Band Elder
2 Last Breath
1 Psychic Intrusion
1 Rescue from the Underworld
1 Scourgemark
1 Thassa's Bounty
1 Traveling Philosopher

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Eternal Weekend

I'm fresh back from Eternal Weekend, a Legacy and Vintage event weekend held in Philadelphia this year under new sponsorship. Even though I know nothing about these two formats, I did have some things I wanted to share.  I'll keep this weeks installment brief, as I have some serious work to get done.

Legacy and Vintage are NOT Dead
I've heard that Legacy is as good as dead.  You've heard that no one plays Vintage anymore.  We've all heard rallying cries that have appeared in articles and on Twitter feeds.  We especially heard it following the death of Extended as a format.  People (important people with a capital 'P') have said that Legacy and Vintage should be retired.  These 'people' said that the formats are both no longer relevant and too expensive.

I'm here to say that what I saw this past weekend proves one of my founding beliefs.  People are sheep.  In this case, I'm specifically referring to the naysayers who said it was time to retire both formats.  The Legacy and Vintage main events fired with over 600 players in total between the two days.  In fact, the Vintage event on Sunday was record breaking, with more attendees playing this 'dead' format than at any previous event on American soil.  These two formats have a great deal of support in the area surrounding Philadelphia.  Having a pro Magic players like Reid Duke topping out to sit at the semi-finalist Vintage table is further proof that some 'people' are simply wrong.

Legacy and Vintage are far from dead, and holding Eternal Weekend in a new venue is the reboot the format needed.

There Ain't No Party...
...like a Nick Coss party.  It's been heard a few times in our region (actually, more than a few).  The TO of Eternal Weekend 2013 is well known for a few reasons.  The number one reason is he's generous almost to a fault with friends and gamers.

At his pre-release events, food is available to the 100+ gamers that attend.  At his PTQs, he offers some of the most aggressive prize structures in Magic.  And when it comes to creative ways to reward players who come to Eternal Weekend, it's easy to see why Nick is such a big guy - it's so that his heart doesn't burst from his chest.

Nick is generous.  He wants people to come back and play again.  And again.  He is a businessman, don't make any mistake about that...but he wants people to have a great time too.  For a case in point, all one had to do was to look at the creative prizes awarded to those who played Vintage on Sunday with a little handicap:

Budget Bonus Prizes!

Highest placing decks without any of the following cards:
The 'Power 9'
Bazaar of Baghdad
Mishra's Workshop
Time Vault
Imperial Seal
1st: $400
2nd: $200
3rd-4th: $100
5th-8th: $50

If you ever have a chance to attend an event in which you hear that Top Deck Games, Card Titan, and/or Nick are even remotely involved in planning and you pass on it, I don't want to hear whining about it later.

Personal Challenge
I don't have deep pockets, nor have I been playing this game for very long.  So I went to Eternal Weekend for a few reasons, none of which included playing in the main events.

Firstly, I wanted to support Top Deck Games and Card Titan, but that's pretty obvious.  Secondly, I wanted to give my son a chance to play a marathon session of limited.  Once events started firing on Saturday, I think he was in four different events.  The MMA was a bit rough, but he made up for it in Theros drafts.  The last, and most personal reason was I wanted to help with the event as a 'Level 1 Judge Candidate'.  I figured if I could help on Friday and Sunday, I could gain some much needed experience.

Things don't always work out the way you anticipate them to.  Friday was a bit slow - so I spent the better part of my time answering questions the L1s and L2s present felt like fielding me.   The patience exhibited by the Judges there was pretty incredible to me, and I wish I had a suitable way to thank them all.  Instead, I'll simply state that Michael Arrowsmith, Matt Hall, & Min Moldover were all excellent in this regard.

On Sunday, it started much the same way.  I sat in on an early meeting held by one of the head judges.  As the morning progressed, I found myself in another question and answer session as there were no side events fired before 10am.  Eventually, the L2 who had been throwing question after question at me asked if I was testing this weekend.  Leading up to the weekend I had made a decision not to test.  I still felt I had a lot to learn regarding the rules.  But Michael's apparent confidence in me when he asked the question got me thinking that I could do it.  So when he proposed I take the L1 practice test, I agreed.

I'm still not sure what the name of that freight train was that ran me over, but it was big.

Since I hadn't yet passed my Rules Adviser test (a prerequisite for taking a L1 Practice Test), one of the other Judges, Simon Cooper, brought out his personal laptop and helped me log into Judge Center.  I created a RA test and sat down to take it.  Over the next 50 minutes or so, I wrestled with 25 rules questions about card interactions.

The score I received was low.  Aside from me writing about it now, we shall never speak of this RA test again.  I was disheartened and embarrassed.  Thoughts that ran through my head included things like, "Wow, these guys have spent hours with you this weekend and this is how you perform?" to "A (Score redacted to protect the innocent and my already bruised psyche)%?  Go home, loser."  I wanted to curl up in the fetal position and make it all go away.

Instead, I went to get some lunch.  The sun was out, the weather was beautiful and the Reading Terminal Market was around the corner.  I consoled myself with a pulled pork sandwich from Dinic's.  I even splurged and bought a couple cookies from one of the many bakeries.  When I was done, I sat down with Min Moldover, who spent easily an hour going over the questions I missed and helped me to see where I made mistakes.  It was painful - many mistakes were due to simple reasons.   I missed most of the questions by 'that' much - I wasn't far off on any of my answers.  And what was even worse?  Min actually said to me one of my problems with a particular question was, 'reading comprehension.'

Ahem.  ME?  Reading comprehension?  Surely you mean the other Magic Dad, right?

When Min was done with me, I felt again like curling up into the fetal position.  I also wanted to turn around and retake the RA right then and there, to prove I wasn't stupid (which was the way I felt and had no bearing in any way to the way Min treated me).  I wanted to punch a wall.  Instead, I did none of those things.  I grabbed a box of product and fired off the first of a half dozen Theros drafts.

I know Judges talk, so I'm sure that my score...or at least my poor performance was shared with more than a few people who wore black shirts that day.  I'm ok with that.  I'm sure while my performance was shared, most didn't know my name or wouldn't be able to pick me out of a police lineup six months from now.  The people who do matter, the ones who will remember me, won't remember this test, taken on a beautiful fall day during Eternal Weekend 2013.

Why?

Because next time I take that test, I will KICK IT'S POSTERIOR PLUMP MID-REGION INTO NEXT MONTH.  And when I take my L1, I'm going to do the same.

A singular screw up is one thing.  But now I know where I'm lacking and I'm working diligently to fix it.  Min and Michael will be proud of me when I'm done.  I may not write much in the next few weeks.  You see, I have a test to study for.

__________________________

Closing Comments:
Thank you Matt Wall, Liz Richardson, Dimah Eroshkin, Simon Cooper, Nicola Dipasquale and Mike Noss.  Special thanks to Min Moldover and Micheal Arrowsmith, two princes among Judges.

Also, a special shout out to Kate C. on Twitter.  Her compliment regarding my youngest was wonderful to receive.  Players, if you do play against a well-mannered child, be sure to let their parents know.  They love to hear it and it reinforces behavior (whether you see it or not) that we want all young players to exhibit.


Reblogs, Retweets, & Mentions of all kinds are appreciated - as an independent writer I'm only read when others like what they see and share with their friends.


Friday, October 18, 2013

Sitting at the Big Table

I have a few memories from my childhood that I cherish.  Running through the grass not wearing any shoes on a spring day.  Finding a million and one uses for rather large magnifying lens that my stepbrother let me 'borrow'.  The day I permanently moved to live with my dad.  There are many more, but there is one that sticks with me that I want to share with you today.  It has to do with Magic, socialization, and growing up.

Large Families, Small Table
During the holidays, large family gatherings were common occurrences.  Thanksgiving and Christmas especially were reason enough to gather, but anytime one of my 2 uncles came in from the west coast special attempts were made to get everyone together.

Anyone who comes from a large family is probably familiar with the result.  Picture if you will, grandma and a few aunts cooking in the kitchen, occasionally chasing out the foraging menfolk and children.  Older adult siblings likely telling stories with younger adult siblings arguing about every small detail, up to and including what the weather really was like that day they both fell out of the boat 3 miles from shore.  The multiple attempts to keep the youngest children occupied while the older children do everything in their power to stave off boredom (this was pre-Internet people, with 5 channels on tv).  In short, a picture of a large and loving slice of Americana.

As dinner time nears, two tables are set.  There is the large banquet sized table that has had 3 leaves added to it so it can seemingly seat a million people (but it only sits 10, 11 in a pinch).  And then there is the 'kiddie table'.  It's an abused card table that has been drafted into service.  The table looks lonely, set off to the side and lacking the same level of sophistication seen on the larger table.  Often, its settings were common dishware or in some circumstances, 'fine china', aka paper plates, would be employed.  Even the difference in height spoke volumes.  Those that sat at this table were 'less than' those that sat at the adult table.  This lonely island in a room of cheer was my purgatory for many years.

From the kiddie table, even as young as five, I would watch my father and the rest of his family engage in rousing discussions and tale telling.  While I never felt as a child that I wasn't watched or unloved as a result of sitting at the smaller table, I did know that I was also thought of as unready to join my older relations.  I was ostracized due in no small part to my inexperience.  My grandmother would take a particularly keen interest in my table, making certain no one left hungry.  More importantly, she suffered no ridiculous behavior, often swooping in to check on us all or gazing at me from her perch at the adults table.

Nothing would have made me happier than to join the adults.  Unless my older cousin was in town, I was the oldest at the table and as the years moved on I was expected to help manage my younger sister and cousins.  The privilege of leadership though didn't diminish my feelings.  I felt that I was sure I had proven myself trustworthy enough to sit at the big table and it got to the point when I was twelve or thirteen that I felt I was being punished by my placement.

One holiday though, everything changed when I was promoted.  I don't remember my age at the time that it happened, likely because I viewed it as a natural, yet overdue, progression.  I'm sure it happened one year when an uncle didn't fly in to join us, or when someone perhaps discovered a fourth leaf for the table.  Regardless of the reason, I found myself seated to my father's left.  Eating off of the fine china didn't impress me (even though I was VERY careful with it).  What did impress me though was finally being included in all of the conversations that happened that night.  Even though I had been watching the adults for years, I was still a little uncomfortable.  I distinctly remember feeling bashful and awkward when it came to talking with and answering questions from my relations.  I was probably 14 at the time, but it still took a few more years of practice at the big family table before I really felt comfortable.

I made myself a promise following that evening.  I vowed to never have my children, if I was so lucky to find some woman weird enough to have children with, sit at a separate table at family gatherings.  Over the past twenty-one years, I've kept that promise, both figuratively and literally.  I have taken steps in the past to protect my boys - but when it comes to introducing them to social challenges, I've given them many opportunities to prove themselves.

MtG - It's All a Big Table
Magic the Gathering represents a wonderful example of equality, completely different than my family's holiday seating arrangements.  Certainly, younger players can sit and play a casual game separately  from other players.  But when you start talking about the competitive environment, everyone has an equal chance to participate.

Drafting at my LGS on Friday nights is a perfect example.  Somewhere between 16 and 35 players gather, pay the entry fee and are seated into pods using a randomizer built into Wizards Event Reporter.  WER doesn't care how old you are or how many drafts you've played before when it seats you.  It just throws your name in and churns out a seating arrangement.  The system plays no favorites and pulls no punches.  It can result in some wickedly difficult pods for novice players to be seated into, but by the same extension the randomness of the seating also allows for pods to be formed with lower skill levels as well.

And then there are larger events.  PTQs.  Grand Prix.  States.  All of these are democratic as well, with first round pairings being completely random.  You could just as easily find yourself at table 1,000 as table 1.

All of this means that at 40 years old, I can find myself seated against a almost anyone in the room.  And so can my son, Jacob.  While we've both been playing for the same amount of time, Jacob is only twelve and his grasp of the rules isn't as strong as mine.  He's learning an important lesson though every time he sits down to play.

No one is going to roll over for him because of his age, and everyone is forced to respect him as a player.

There is no kiddie table in competitive MtG.  There's also no 'Under 16' age division.  Jacob has to find his seat, sometimes in a hall with 2000 chairs.  He has to get himself there on time, ready to play.  He has to get out his gear, shuffle his deck and confirm the person across from him is his opponent.  At his first competitive experience last year, that was both confusing and educational.  On his second match, he didn't remember the correct table number when he went to find it, costing him time and nearly resulting in a game loss for tardiness.  MtG is about equality - if he wants to play it competitively he has to overcome mistakes like that.

Better than teaching him some small lessons about responsibility, competitive MtG gives him something else that is more important.  Jacob has to meet, play, and talk to people that are on average at least twice his age in just about every match-up.  This is one of the many reasons I'm so supportive of his playing the game.  He doesn't sit off at some table at events and just stare at his cards and try to pick up games with other kids his age (who are very few and far between).  And he certainly doesn't gaze longingly at some group of players engaged in a draft because he's shut out due to age or inexperience [Note: the 'inexperience' example is for the most part no longer valid].  Instead, he jumps right into open queues, often seated in pods with at least 5-6 players capable of growing facial hair.

Why is this a big deal and worth writing about?

Jacob's self-esteem is on par with any other youth 4-6 years older than he is.  He has no problem engaging adults in conversation.  He talks with them respectfully, but at the same time there is a measure of equality in his discussions.  Certainly, there is the youthful exuberance and tendency to oversell a point in a story that one would expect of a pre-teen.  But the fear one often sees when younger children speak with adults is almost non-existent.

A small part of me is cringing, thinking I may be setting myself up for some blowback in the feedback section, so please allow me a chance to clarify.  He's not untrained in stranger danger, nor is he going to strike up a conversation with a guy driving a van near his bus stop.  MtG Tournaments are reasonably safe environments, and he is often in sight of me or has a cell phone with him.  He also knows to call for a Judge if and when something bothers him or gets out of his control.  So please, reserve any criticism you may have in this area.

This confidence does extend beyond Magic.  Recently, I saw him at a non-MtG related meeting of other kids his age and older.  He was asked to present an opinion on a topic he had researched.  Unhesitatingly, he walked to the front of the room, turned around and spoke for five minutes straight on a topic with no notes at hand and more importantly, zero fear.  He smiled.  He scanned the crowd, looking at other kids (some as old as 17).  He spoke to them, not above them or at the floor.  He was absolutely charismatic - well, as charismatic as a 12 year old can be.  When he finished talking, he took questions and handled the group of 20 other boys as if he were a teacher.  Was I proud?  You bet I was.

But it was only upon reflection later that night that I really understood how proud I was of him.  The funny thing is, I've come to expect it of Jacob.  The confidence and ability to speak with his friends is something I've started to take for granted as something that he simply does.

MtG: The Equalizer
Magic isn't just about offering people valuable lessons in a Mensa level game.  It's not just about teaching them to them to do math quickly in their head or how to read at an advanced level.  We call it a 'Social Game' all the time.  And that is what is about.

Magic, whether you are comfortable with it or not, is about interaction.

Certainly, the game has its share of bashful Barry's.  Players who don't socialize well, but still continue to come out to LGSs and play because the enjoyment of the game is strong enough to overcome their reticence.  I'm happy they continue to come out.  Maybe one day they'll overcome whatever is lying in their way and come out of their shell.  I anxiously await those days and I'm confident it will happen for many.

Until then, I'm proud of the progress Jacob has made.  He hasn't yet figured out how to 3-0 drafts (although my wallet would love that).  I'm referring of course to his progress in his social development.  Perhaps he'll be the catalyst to one day help someone else come out of their shell.  Or maybe he'll just continue to break the curve, acting in ways that defy his age.  No matter what though, I know I'll continue to challenge him with new opportunities.  So long as he promises to pass the mac'n cheese.  I hate it when he sits at the opposite end of the table from me and hoards the good stuff.
__________________________________

This article, as many of my pieces, deserves a couple of end notes:
First, if your child is nine or ten years old and interested in MtG, take them occasionally to a draft at an LGS.  Invite them along to play some Standard.  Allow them a chance to sit at the big table.  You can't tell me they aren't ready until they'd had a chance to prove it.

Secondly, Jacob does receive other chances to socialize with adults in other structured settings.  However, none of them require him to meet and speak with new adults a tenth as often as Magic does.  Involving Jacob in larger, competitive settings even occasionally drives up this percentage a thousandfold more.

Lastly, MtG is not a panacea for social development.  People still have to be willing to learn.  If you give a pre-teen age child though opportunity and challenges in the guise of a game, you should be prepared for some potentially remarkable results.

Reblogs, Retweets, & Mentions of all kinds are appreciated - as an independent writer I'm only read when others like what they see and share with their friends.


A special note...
A good friend of mine is responsible for Eternal Weekend in a few weeks.  As of this writing, there are still pre-registration slots open to score a wicked, one-of-a-kind Tarmagoyf playmat.  Believe me, this offer won't last much longer.  So if you're into Vintage or Legacy, click on the link to find out more about it: